Best Crossbows of 2024: My Top Picks for Hunters & Target Practice

Here are some of the top picks for crossbows of three different calibers, the recurve, compound, and reverse draw. Let's take a look at what makes them great.

Have you ever wondered what makes the best crossbows stand out in the wild or at the range? Here, we will dive into the world of top-tier crossbows, uncovering the nuances that make them worthy of the title.

By the end of our exploration, you’ll not only grasp the key features of these top contenders but also gain insight into which one might be the best for you.

Key takeaways

  • My top recommendation is the Excalibur Mag 340.
  • Recurve crossbows are lightweight, quieter, and harder to cock.
  • Compound crossbows are complex, powerful, and suitable for long-range.
  • Reverse Draw Crossbows are efficient and compact, but expensive.

Best recurve

Excalibur Mag 340 Recurve Crossbow

Best crossbows of 2024: my top picks for hunters & target practice | 61dzkbrv8ul. Ac sl1500 | country crossbow
5/5
Check Amazon PriceCheck Walmart Price

Best compound

Barrett Whitetail Hunter II Crossbow

Barnett Whitetail Hunter II Crossbow
5/5
Check Amazon PriceCheck Walmart Price

What is a crossbow and why it matters

Crossbows are not just the medieval weapons you see in the action-packed scenes of fantasy series like “Game of Thrones”; they are sophisticated tools for modern hunters and sports enthusiasts. A crossbow is a ranged weapon using an elastic launching device similar to a bow; it consists of a bow-like assembly mounted on a frame called a tiller. Hunters and target archers care about the best crossbows because:

Best crossbows of 2024: my top picks for hunters & target practicehere are some of the top picks for crossbows of three different calibers, the recurve, compound, and reverse draw. Let's take a look at what makes them great.
Image Of A Modern Recurve Crossbow With A Detailed Camouflage Pattern On The Body Dall E
  • They offer a unique challenge different from traditional firearms.
  • Stealthy hunting becomes possible as crossbows are quieter than guns.
  • Precision and power are combined, making for a more humane and effective hunt.

Which crossbows are the best in 2024?

Selecting the right crossbow isn’t just about hitting the target; it’s about matching your gear to your goals, terrain, and the type of game you’re pursuing. Whether you’re perched in a treestand waiting for that whitetail or stalking elk through the brush, the right crossbow feels like an extension of your own arm—intuitive, reliable, and deadly accurate.

#1

Best crossbows of 2024: my top picks for hunters & target practice | 61dzkbrv8ul. Ac sl1500 | country crossbow

Best recurve for beginners

Excalibur Mag 340

5/5
Check Price

#2

Barnett Whitetail Hunter II Crossbow

Best for compound for beginners

Barrett Whitetail Hunter II Crossbow

5/5
Check Price

#3

Best crossbows of 2024: my top picks for hunters & target practice | 71yzeq+ckol. Ac sl1500 | country crossbow

Best reverse-draw

TenPoint Siege RS410 Crossbow

5/5
Check Price

1. Best recurve for beginners

Best crossbows of 2024: my top picks for hunters & target practice | 61dzkbrv8ul. Ac sl1500 | country crossbow
5/5

Our rating is based on our five-point ranking criteria checklist.

Excalibur Mag 340

  • Best-in-class performance with accuracy and durability
  • Comes fully equipped with necessary hunting accessories
  • Rope Cocking Aid reduces draw weight by up to 50%
  • Dead Zone Scope with premium optics for clear targeting
  • Comfortable and silent with R.E.D.S. suppressors for stealth
  • Easy to use quiver with quick-twist locking screw
Check Amazon PriceCheck Walmart Price

We may earn a commission if you make a purchase at no additional cost to you.

Pros
  • Crisp trigger and easy to zero
  • Scope clarity, excellent in low light
  • Small, light, and well-balanced for freehand shots
Cons
  • Heavy to cock, particularly the last inch
  • Some parts may arrive scratched or with stripped bolts

Why I picked it

I picked this bad boy because it’s a real workhorse. First time I took it out, I couldn’t believe how it combined power with such smooth handling. It’s a straight shooter, through and through, and the comfort in cocking and silence in the shoot? That’s just the cherry on top.

The gear that comes with it? It’s like Christmas morning. Rope Cocking Aid, Dead Zone Scope, R.E.D.S. Suppressors—the whole nine yards. You’re set up straight out of the box. And it has a nice easy-to-use quiver.

Now, I’ve heard some folks had a bit of a tiff with parts coming scratched or bolts being a pain. My advice? Give it a once-over when you get it, and don’t be shy to holler at customer service if something’s off. Excalibur’s usually on point with their lifetime warranty.

Here’s the bottom line: for a crossbow that won’t have you eating ramen for a month to afford it, the Excalibur Mag 340 recurve crossbow is a true shot. You’ll be hittin’ bullseyes and fillin’ freezers in no time. Just remember to get yourself an arrow puller, ’cause you’ll need it—those bolts get snug as a bug in a rug.

Who it’s for

This rig’s for the mid-level archer who values precision and comfort out in the woods. If you’re dealing with shoulder issues or just want a dependable partner on the hunt, the Excalibur Mag 340’s your ticket.

What people are saying

Folks out there are singing the same tune: this crossbow is a game-changer. One fella mentioned how he had it zeroed in just a few shots, talking about a trigger so crisp it could snap an apple in half. And that scope? Clear as a mountain stream. But it ain’t all sunshine; some have griped about it being a bit tough to cock, and a few unlucky ones got their gear with some scratches and stripped bolts. Still, for a crossbow that doesn’t bleed your wallet dry, it’s got folks nodding in agreement—it’s a solid pick.

2. Best compound for beginners

Barnett Whitetail Hunter II Crossbow
5/5

Our rating is based on our five-point ranking criteria checklist.

Barrett Whitetail Hunter II Crossbow

  • Durability: Withstands rough handling and environments.
  • Power and Accuracy: Proven track record with bucks, does, and wild pigs.
  • Ease of Maintenance: Simple hose off and re-lube keeps it in top shape.
  • Value for Money: Excellent performance without breaking the bank.
  • Scope Quality: Adequate for beginners; easily upgradeable for veterans.
Check Amazon PriceCheck Walmart Price

We may earn a commission if you make a purchase at no additional cost to you.

Pros
  • Very accurate and fast
  • Handles abuse well and easy to clean
  • Good price for the quality
Cons
  • The included scope is basic
  • Can be loud upon firing
  • Assembly instructions could be clearer

Why I picked it

I reckon I chose this compound crossbow ’cause it’s as tough as they come. Whether I’m trudging through mud or bounding over hills on my quad, it’s a trusty companion that never lets up. It’s not about the fancy features; it’s about a tool that does its job every time, without a fuss. A real deal for a fella like me who just wants to hunt without worrying about gear failing. Hers some real deal benefits:

  • You’re getting a beast that can take a beating.
  • Won’t let you down when it’s crunch time.
  • Heck, for the price, you’re stealing it.

Who it’s for

This Barnett beauty is a perfect match for the hardy soul who’s not afraid to get their hands dirty. It’s for the guy or gal who needs something reliable that they can drag through the underbrush or strap to their ATV without a second thought. This ain’t a high-maintenance piece; it’s for someone who needs their gear ready at a moment’s notice, whether that’s hanging in the garage or out in the field. If you’re just breaking into the crossbow game or looking to trade in your old timer for something solid, this is your huckleberry.

What people are saying

Folks who’ve laid hands on this crossbow have a lot to say. They’re praising it to high heaven for its accuracy and speed—knocking down game left and right. One hunter even bagged a deer at 62 yards, though they prefer to keep it under 45. It’s not just for show; this crossbow delivers. But they ain’t wearing rose-colored glasses either—some have a bone to pick with the scope and the noise it makes.

They say it’s a little on the loud side and that scope? Good for a laugh, but many ditch it for something better. The assembly instructions could use some work too, it seems. But tell you what, for all the rough and tumble, this crossbow keeps coming back for more. It’s a trooper—just hose it off, re-lube, and it’s like new.

3. Best reverse-draw

Best crossbows of 2024: my top picks for hunters & target practice | 71yzeq+ckol. Ac sl1500 | country crossbow
5/5

Our rating is based on our five-point ranking criteria checklist.

TenPoint Siege RS410 Crossbow

  • Compact & Comfortable: 26.5″ long, 7.5″ wide, with adjustable butt plate.
  • Fast & Accurate: 410 FPS, same-hole accuracy with EVO-X arrows.
  • Low-Light Precision: RangeMaster Pro scope with lighted points.
  • Top-Notch Trigger: 3.5-pound, two-stage S1 trigger.
  • Silent & Safe: ACUslide for quiet cocking, safe de-cocking.
  • Durable String: MICRO-TRAC barrel halves string wear.
Check Amazon PriceCheck Walmart Price

We may earn a commission if you make a purchase at no additional cost to you.

Pros
  • Exceptional compactness for ease of handling.
  • High velocity and precision in shots.
  • Advanced scope enhances low-light hunting.
Cons
  • Lacks an arrow safety feature for bolt engagement.
  • Poor quality control and instruction manual issues.
  • High restocking fee for returns.

Why I picked it

Let me tell ya, this reverse-draw TenPoint Siege RS410 is a beast in the woods. It’s not just about the features – it’s the feeling of trust and power you get. When you’re out there, lined up for the perfect shot, it’s this crossbow that won’t let you down. Its silent operation and deadly accuracy are what make it stand out. It’s not just a crossbow; it’s a hunter’s best companion.

  • Feel the Difference: Experience the thrill of silent stalking and precise targeting.
  • Hunting Made Easier: Its compact design makes maneuvering in dense woods a breeze.
  • Peace of Mind: Safety and reliability that lets you focus on the hunt.

Who it’s for

This TenPoint Siege RS410 is perfect for the experienced hunter who demands nothing but the best. If you’re the kind who lives for the thrill of the hunt, who values precision, speed, and reliability, then this crossbow’s for you. It’s not for the faint-hearted or the occasional hobbyist. This is for the hunter who knows what they want and isn’t afraid to go deep into the wilderness to get it.

What people are saying

Folks are saying this crossbow is as tough as nails and accurate as a laser. One hunter mentioned it’s their third TenPoint and they can’t get enough of its precision. They even have to adjust their aim to avoid wrecking their bolts!

But, not all’s perfect – some are griping about the lack of a bolt safety feature, causing a nasty dry fire. Plus, there’s chatter about some shoddy quality control and a confusing manual that’s more of a puzzle than a guide. Despite these hiccups, the consensus is clear: for those who know their way around a bow, this is a top-notch choice. Just be ready to overlook a few flaws for that top-tier performance.

Things to consider when buying a crossbow

  1. Draw Weight: This is the force required to pull the string back into the locked position. A higher draw weight translates to more power, but it also means more effort to cock the crossbow.
  2. Bow Weight: The overall weight of the crossbow affects stability and portability. A heavier crossbow may offer more stability while shooting, but it can become cumbersome on longer treks.
  3. Speed (FPS): The arrow velocity, measured in feet per second (FPS), is critical for a swift, clean kill when hunting. However, higher speed can mean a trade-off with other features like noise level and draw weight.
  4. Noise Level: Stealth is crucial in hunting; a quiet crossbow will minimize the chance of startling game. Some crossbows come with built-in dampening systems to reduce noise.
  5. Size and Cocking Mechanism: The physical size of the crossbow should fit the shooter comfortably, and the cocking mechanism should be manageable. Crank cocking devices can reduce the effort needed to cock heavier crossbows.
  6. Accuracy and Precision: Look for crossbows with enhanced accuracy features like scopes and precision triggers.
  7. Safety Features: Safety mechanisms such as anti-dry fire (ADF) and auto-engaging safety locks are essential to prevent accidental discharge and injuries.
  8. Build Quality and Durability: The construction of the crossbow should withstand regular use and the elements. Durable materials like machined aluminum and composite polymers are often used in high-quality models.
  9. Price: Determine your budget beforehand, but remember that with crossbows, you often get what you pay for. Higher-priced models typically offer better features and longevity.
  10. Warranty and Brand Reputation: A good warranty can save you from headaches down the road. Also, purchasing from a reputable brand ensures access to customer service and parts.
  11. User Reviews and Field Testing: Check out reviews and field tests from other users to see how the crossbow performs in real-world conditions.
  12. Arrows and Broadheads: Ensure that the crossbow is compatible with a range of arrows and broadheads to suit your intended use.
  13. Maintenance Requirements: Consider how much maintenance the crossbow will need and how easy it is to perform that maintenance.
  14. Accessories and Upgrades: Some crossbows come with essential accessories like a scope, while others allow for upgrades. Determine what’s included and what you’ll need to purchase separately.
  15. Legal Requirements: Make sure the crossbow meets all legal requirements for hunting in your area, as regulations can vary widely.

Dos and don’ts of crossbow hunting

When it comes to crossbow hunting, there’s a fine line between a successful outing and a day filled with frustrations. Here’s a quick rundown of some dos and don’ts to help keep you on target.

DoDon’t
Always practice with the same bolts you’ll hunt with.Never dry-fire your crossbow; it can cause damage.
Regularly inspect and maintain your crossbow.Don’t neglect to check local laws and regulations.
Use a cocking device for consistent accuracy.Avoid using a damaged or frayed string.
Keep your crossbow’s rail and string lubricated.Don’t handle or load a crossbow until ready to shoot.
Proper crossbow etiquette ensures safety and effectiveness in the field.

Advantages and disadvantages of crossbows

Crossbow hunting is an ancient practice that continues to gain popularity in modern times. With technological advancements, the sport has evolved significantly, but like any pursuit, it has its ups and downs.

Advantages

  • Allows for a longer hunting season in some areas.
  • Suitable for hunters with physical limitations that prevent them from using traditional bows.
  • Greater accuracy and power than traditional bows.
  • Quiet operation compared to firearms.

Disadvantages

  • Crossbows can be heavy and cumbersome to carry.
  • They have a slower rate of fire than traditional bows.
  • Legal restrictions can be more stringent in some areas.
  • They require significant maintenance and care.

Additional crossbow hunting tips

So, you’ve got the gear, but what about the game? Here are some additional tips to make sure you’re making the most out of your crossbow hunting:

  • Understand your crossbow’s range – Know the maximum effective distance for your specific model.
  • Match the broadhead to the game – Choose the right broadhead for the type of game you’re hunting.
  • Keep up with maintenance – A well-maintained crossbow means a reliable one in the field.
  • Be mindful of your surroundings – Always have a clear line of sight and backstop before shooting.
  • Patience is key – Wait for the perfect shot; rushing can lead to missed opportunities or wounded animals.
  • Keep it safeGet a strong case.

If you are more of a visual learner, here is a relevant video for more information.

Frequently asked questions (FAQ)

How do you choose the right broadhead for your crossbow?

Selecting the right broadhead is crucial; it should correspond with the game you’re pursuing. For larger game, you’ll want a broadhead that delivers maximum penetration, while for smaller game, one that ensures a wider cut is preferable. Always choose broadheads that are compatible with your crossbow’s draw weight and bolt length for optimum performance. Find the perfect match for your hunting style here.

What’s the ideal draw weight for a hunting crossbow?

The ideal draw weight for a hunting crossbow typically ranges between 150 to 200 pounds. This provides a good balance between power and manageability, ensuring that you can take down game efficiently without the crossbow being too strenuous to handle. However, the specific draw weight you should choose depends on the game size and the hunting regulations in your area.

Can you use a crossbow for competitive shooting?

Absolutely, crossbows can be used for competitive shooting. There are specific categories and competitions designed for crossbow enthusiasts. Precision and accuracy are tested in these competitions, much like with other forms of archery. It’s a great way to hone skills and enjoy the sport outside of the hunting season.

Final thoughts

I’ll be the first to say that my early days with a crossbow were not, by any stretch, a highlight reel. I remember fumbling with the cocking device, the awkwardness of loading bolts, and yes, I’m embarrassed to admit, that heart-sinking ‘thud’ of a dry fire. But with each outing, my technique sharpened, my shots became more precise, and eventually, the pieces clicked—quite literally.

Wrapping up our crossbow saga, we’ve aimed to equip you with knowledge sharper than the finest broadhead. From the silent but deadly stalk in the wilds to the disciplined aim on the range, crossbows offer a thrilling challenge that’s hard to match. Take your skills to the next level with more insights.

And did I cover everything you wanted to know? Let me know in the comments section below. I read and reply to every comment. If you found this article helpful, share it with a friend, and check out my full blog for more tips and tricks on crossbow hunting. Thanks for reading and may your aim always be true.

Clint Cadwell
Written by Clint Cadwell, Staff Writer

Howdy! I'm Clint, a relative newbie finding my footing in the world of hunting and archery. And I’m loving every second of it. If you're curious about crossbow hunting or on a similar journey as mine, Country Crossbow is the place for you.

Nick eggert.
Edited by Nick Eggert, Staff Editor

Nick is our staff editor and co-founder. He has a passion for writing, editing, and website development. His expertise lies in shaping content with precision and managing digital spaces with a keen eye for detail.

Verified User Black 24dp

Fact-Checked

Our team conducts thorough evaluations of every article, guaranteeing that all information comes from reliable sources.

Event Available Black 24dp

Up-to-Date

We diligently maintain our content, regularly updating articles to ensure they reflect the most recent information.

Leave a Comment